Pairing Smells

Tim Ottinger and I are working on a new project, an agile agile reference guide. (Yes, that’s supposed to be two “agile”s in a row.) One of the things we’re debating is a list of pairing smells. Here’s what we have so far:

  • Unequal access to keyboard and/or screen
  • Keyboard domination
  • Pair marriages / no switching during story
  • Worker/rester pairing
  • Second computer
  • “Everyone does their own work”
  • 90% of stories 90% done
  • Reluctant pairings
  • Debates lasting longer than 10 minutes with no new code

Thoughts welcome, and incorporated ideas will be rightly attributed. What might we remove from or add to this list? What could be worded better?

  1. jlangr Reply

    [ Jeff’s note: Post moved from old blog. Original comments appear here: ]

    James Carr said…
    What about extreme newbie / extreme expert pairing? I’ve seen some pretty bad pairing happen when you have someone who is pretty well skilled paired with someone with very poor skills… it gets hectic.

    Good list though… I’ve seen a few of these. 😉

    11/03/2008 07:04:00 PM
    Anonymous said…
    I wouldn’t place “second computer” in that list. I’ve paired where the second computer is used as a resource to look up an API, run unit tests, check the build, etc. I recognize that the second computer could be misused but don’t think it’s an automatic smell.

    11/04/2008 01:12:00 PM
    Jeff L. said…
    The term “smell” to me is open-ended–smells can be either aromas that we can live with or stenches that must be eradicated. So I think James’ smell could go on the list; sometimes it’s not a bad thing to pair expert and novice, particularly if you have the goal that a novice shouldn’t stay so green very long.

    The same thing goes for second computer–it’s a scent that must be investigated further.

    11/06/2008 07:36:00 AM
    Igor said…
    I had a pleasure to pair with two keyboards connected to one computer.
    It was quiet interesting experience, which I personally think could mitigate “keyboard domination” smell.

    11/06/2008 05:13:00 PM

Leave a Reply


captcha *